One way in which law protects dignity is by enforcing human rights provisions that explictly or implicitly involve the protection of dignity or the prevention of degradation. But law's connection with dignity is also much deeper and more pervasive than this. In the way that it operates, in the way that it presents its requirements, in the way law expects its requirements to be taken on baord and observed by those to whom the requirements are primarily addressed, in the procedural way that it organizes hearings, in the way that it sponsors argumentation, even in the way that it arranages for coercion--in all these ways, law treats humans as dignified agents, capable of self-control, with a sense of themsleves and their interests, and with the ability to respond intelligently and thoughtfully to its demands. These ideas, which originate with some comments by Lon Fuller, in "The Morality of Law," are developed extensively in the present paper. Of course it is true that law is sometimes brutal and degrading in its application; but the paper argues that it is part of law's inherently aspirational character to deal with human persons as dignified agents, and that this distinguishes legal forms of control from other modes of governance.
Date of Authorship for this Version
agency, coercion, dignity, Fuller, legal argument, legal process, normativity, procedures, representation, respect, rights, rule of law
Waldron, Jeremy J., "How Law Protects Dignity" (2012). New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers. Paper 317.
Civil Procedure Commons, Courts Commons, Criminal Law Commons, Ethics and Professional Responsibility Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Legal History, Theory and Process Commons, Legal Profession Commons, Public Law and Legal Theory Commons